Home
Exit
Topic Arjuna's Dilemma: The Conflict Between Personal Attachment and National Duty

The Bhagavad Gītā begins not with a philosophical discourse, but with a human crisis. The first chapter introduces us to Arjuna, one of the greatest warriors of his age, standing on the battlefield of Kurukṣetra. Before discussing yoga, spirituality, or liberation, the Gītā first presents a conflict of mind. This chapter explains why Arjuna became unwilling to fight and why Lord Krishna decided to instruct him.
The chapter opens with King Dhṛtarāṣṭra asking Sañjaya:

"What did my sons and the sons of Pāṇḍu do when they assembled in Kurukṣetra, the field of Dharma, eager for battle?" (1.1)

According to the translation uploaded, Kurukṣetra is described as the land earmarked for fighting a war for Dharma. The battlefield therefore represents not merely a geographical location but a place where justice and righteousness are to be decided.
After observing the well-organized Pāṇḍava army, Duryodhana approaches his teacher Droṇa. He praises the strength of the opposing army, lists its distinguished warriors, and then names the principal commanders of his own army. Finally, he instructs everyone to protect Bhīṣma, the commander of the Kaurava forces.
The commencement of the battle is marked by the blowing of conches. Bhīṣma first sounds his conch, followed by the combined instruments of the Kaurava army. In response, Krishna, Arjuna, and all the leading warriors of the Pāṇḍava side blow their respective conches, creating a tremendous sound that shakes both the earth and the sky and pierces the hearts of the Kauravas.
Before the battle begins, Arjuna requests Krishna:

"Park my chariot between the two armies so that I may see those assembled here for battle." (1.21–23)

Krishna places the chariot between the two armies, directly before Bhīṣma, Droṇa, and the assembled kings. When Arjuna surveys both armies, he sees not strangers but his own elders, teachers, grandfathers, brothers, sons, grandsons, relatives, friends, and fathers-in-law standing ready to fight one another.
This sight completely changes Arjuna's mental state.
He describes his physical symptoms:

  • His limbs fail.
  • His mouth becomes dry.
  • His body trembles.
  • His hair stands on end.
  • His bow, Gāṇḍīva, slips from his hand.
  • His skin burns.
  • His mind becomes confused and unsteady.

Arjuna then presents several arguments against the war.

1. War Cannot Bring Him Happiness

He declares that he desires neither victory, kingdom, nor pleasures because those for whose sake these things are desired are themselves standing on the battlefield prepared to sacrifice their lives.

2. Killing Relatives Will Bring Sin

Arjuna states that even if the sons of Dhṛtarāṣṭra are aggressors, killing one's own relatives would lead only to pāpa (downgradation), not happiness.

3. Destruction of Family Values

According to Arjuna, destruction of families causes the disappearance of eternal family values. Once family values are lost, vice dominates society.

4. Harm to Women and Society

The uploaded translation explains Arjuna's concern that when vice prevails, women in society are humiliated by corrupt persons, leading to an admixture of good and bad values among people.

5. Downfall of Future Generations

Arjuna further argues that the destruction of family traditions causes the downfall of both families and society, resulting in the erosion of eternal human values and family values.
Finally, Arjuna concludes that it would be better for him to remain unarmed and be killed than to kill his own relatives merely for the sake of a kingdom. He lays aside his bow and arrows, sits down in the chariot, and becomes overwhelmed with grief. Thus ends the first chapter of the Bhagavad Gītā.
The introductory note provided in the uploaded translation offers the central interpretation of this chapter. It explains that Arjuna initially viewed the war from the standpoint of personal happiness. Since victory would come at the cost of losing his own relatives, he considered the war meaningless. However, Krishna's perspective differs. According to this translation, Krishna maintains that Arjuna's duty is not to fight for personal gain but for the safety and security of the nation, the protection of women, the welfare of humanity, and the removal of destructive and anti-social elements from positions of power. The note concludes with the principle that if a country survives, its citizens survive, and if a country prospers, its citizens prosper.

Conclusion

The first chapter of the Bhagavad Gītā does not resolve Arjuna's dilemma. Instead, it establishes the problem that the remaining eighteen chapters will address. Arjuna's sorrow, confusion, compassion, and moral uncertainty prepare the ground for Krishna's teachings. The chapter demonstrates that even the greatest warrior may become overwhelmed when personal attachment conflicts with duty, and it is this conflict that becomes the starting point of the Bhagavad Gītā's philosophical dialogue.